Developing Critical Thinking Through Problem Based Learning

In my last teaching tip, we explored the benefits of a Place-Based Learning approach. This time, we’ll dive into another PBL: Problem-Based Learning. While Place-Based Learning helps students connect more deeply with content by relating it to their local context, a benefit that can also be a part of Problem-Based Learning, the true strength of Problem-Based Learning lies in its emphasis on developing and practicing critical thinking skills.

A Problem-Based approach can be successful across all modalities, offering flexible options to meet course needs. It can be integrated into an entire course or introduced as a smaller activity. As we will see, the research on Problem-Based Learning is compelling, but it’s important to recognize that implementing PBL often requires additional effort and can feel overwhelming at scale, which will be addressed later on. This teaching tip will define Problem-Based Learning, explore academic insights, and provide practical strategies to help you incorporate PBL into your courses.

Ways of Learning

Traditionally, academic settings prioritize theory and foundational knowledge such as definitions and vocabulary before application, but PBL reverses this by presenting a complex problem right away. While both methods have value, PBL may be rejected due to unfamiliarity with its structure in the academic classroom. Interestingly, we engage in this Problem-Based learning style in our lives on a daily basis. When was the last time you learned something unrelated to your work or professional goals? Or something unexpected? Did it stem from trying something you weren’t prepared for that ended in some perceived failure or frustration?

Over the holiday break, my wife and I decided to move our kitchen cabinets up about six inches to eliminate the gap between them and the ceiling. After a little research, we jumped in. Emptying the cabinets and grabbing the drill, we got to work. Taking down the first cabinet was easy, but holding the cabinet in place, keeping it level, and drilling it into the studs proved challenging. And this was just the first cabinet. Pausing, we realized we couldn’t simply push the cabinets all the way up and drill. The ceiling wasn’t perfectly flat, so the bottom of the cabinets wouldn’t align. This prompted us to engage in some critical thinking to solve the problem. We grabbed a scrap 2×4 from the garage, drilled it into the wall at the desired cabinet height, and rested the cabinet on the 2×4 while drilling it into place. Removing the 2×4 after the cabinet was secured, and then proceeding to the next cabinet. A contractor might see this as obvious, but with our lack of experience and knowledge we had to think critically to solve the problem with the information we had.

Takeaways

  • Problem-Based Learning (PBL) starts with authentic, complex problems, allowing students to develop critical thinking skills by identifying knowledge gaps and working to a solution.
  • PBL can be adapted for various course formats and scales, from small activities to comprehensive curriculum designs.
  • A successful PBL environment is built on a framework that is problem-focused, student-centered, self-directed, and self-reflective. With the role of the instructor primarily being a facilitator to the process.  
  • Incorporating empathy and active listening into PBL activities enhances students’ problem-solving abilities and connection to real-world contexts. ​

This is just one example of how we encounter problems as a way of learning. I am sure you experience similar moments throughout your life. So if we learn this way naturally, why not bring this approach into academic settings? In doing so, it will allow students to practice the same critical thinking they will need for their future lives in the safety of a controlled environment. 

What is PBL?

In the most simplified definition, Problem-Based Learning facilitates learning through authentic problem-solving. “The idea of ‘basics first’ goes out the window in PBL; rather, one learns the basics in the context of meaningful, but ill-structured problem-solving activities” (Marra et al., 2014). While PBL strategies trace back to the teachings of Aristotle, Socrates, and later Dewey, modern PBL is widely credited to the work at McMaster University in Canada during the 1950s (Major et al., 2000).

Frustrations with traditional medical science education, including a lack of practical application and limited critical thinking opportunities, led McMaster University to revamp its medical school curriculum. The new curriculum emphasized small group work with simulated patients, integrating patient interviews, records, and lab results to reach diagnoses. Beyond learning the basics, students developed critical thinking skills, such as analyzing complex data, evaluating multiple sources of information, and making informed decisions, skills not seen in prior instructional strategies (Marra et al., 2014).

Developing critical thinking is an essential skill for our students, not just for their academic careers but also for their professional lives. Practicing these skills can help in navigating workplace challenges, as well as becoming informed citizens with the ability to evaluate societal issues and make sound decisions (Bezanilla et al., 2021).

Given PBL’s inherently messy nature– from its open-ended problems, varying approaches, and unpredictable outcomes– a framework is needed to support its implementation. In their article Why Problem-Based Learning Works: Theoretical Foundations, Marra et al. highlight five primary characteristics of a PBL learning environment:

  • Problem-focused: Let the problem inform the knowledge students must learn to solve it. Problems should be authentic and complex.
  • Student-centered: Students take responsibility for learning what’s needed to address the problem and develop a solution.
  • Self-directed: Collaboration within small groups is essential. Assignments from instructors throughout the process are rare.
  • Self-reflective: Provide space for individual and group reflection throughout the process.
  • Facilitative: Instructors model reasoning processes to facilitate group progress. Answering student questions with questions is a useful strategy.

Ever since McMaster University introduced problem-based learning with its first cohort of medical students in the 1950s, the approach has been the focus of extensive research and numerous academic articles. The variety of ways PBL is implemented has led to differences in how it is defined and practiced. For instance, my first experience with PBL was during an Upward Bound Summer Program in 2021, where we added a few elements to the process before problem solving began. 

In that program, we framed PBL using the Design Thinking Process, which begins with students empathizing with a problem owner to define the problem. This approach introduces a new element to the process: instead of being given a predefined problem, students take responsibility for empathizing and determining what the problem truly is. This is, in fact, the first step in critical thinking, and an essential tool for any critical thinker: identifying the issue. (Browne et al., 2018) This step is highly valuable, as problem owners are often so immersed in their challenges that having an outside group reframe and redefine the problem can significantly improve the problem-solving process.

As you dig deeper, be aware that the terminology surrounding PBL can vary subtly throughout the literature, but following the five characteristics outlined earlier is an excellent starting point for understanding and implementing this approach. If you’re interested in exploring how problem-based learning is applied at other institutions, the articles listed in the reference section provide a strong foundation. Additionally, UAF’s Center for Teaching and Learning plans to host a PBL workshop later this semester, where participants will engage in an abbreviated PBL activity and workshop ways to integrate this method into their courses at a larger scale. For now, we will look at some small steps that can be done to incorporate this approach right away.

Strategies for Incorporating PBL into Your Course

As the literature indicates, there are many ways PBL can be implemented across all modalities. While I’ll share a few suggestions for incorporating these methods, if you have an idea tailored to your course, I encourage you to embrace the spirit of PBL and give it a try. As with any course change, it’s wise to start small. For example, you might test it in an optional bonus module or integrate it as a smaller component of your course.

Since PBL emphasizes solving ill-structured problems before students learn the basics, you might consider incorporating a PBL-style activity at the start of a new topic. Present a complex, topic-related problem to your students before diving into the content. Facilitate the discussion and see where it leads. Ideally, students will identify gaps in their knowledge needed to solve the problem, creating a natural foundation for the unit. This activity works well in both in-person classes as well as Canvas discussions. Not only does this approach prepare students for upcoming material, but it also gives them space to practice critical thinking skills. Keep in mind that PBL is most effective in small groups, which will help facilitate the critical thinking process (Seibert 2020). The size of these groups may vary depending on the structure or modality of your course.

Another excellent option is to invite a community member or someone in the industry related to your course to participate in the activity. While PBL is great for developing critical thinking, one of its most rewarding aspects, especially as we implemented it in the Upward Bound Summer Program, is its ability to provide space for students to practice empathy and active listening. Imagine using the previous activity but instead of you presenting the problem, an industry professional poses it, and students work to define the problem first, resulting in a more connected problem solving discussion. If you take this approach, be sure to scaffold the activity with a discussion on empathy and active listening. There are many resources available on empathy and active listening but I find that Brene Brown’s work on these topics is particularly helpful, and her short video on empathy is an excellent resource to share with students.

A third option is for instructors that are teaching capstone or practicum courses. These courses are often Problem-Based by nature, but taking some of the insights in current PBL research and embracing the five primary characteristics of a PBL environment could greatly improve the delivery of these courses. Focusing on having the students identify the gaps in their knowledge throughout the semester while ensuring that they are critically thinking about their project rather than expecting all of their questions to be answered immediately.

As teachers we want our students to succeed, and when working in a Problem-Based setting it can be way too easy to be impatient and push the students to that perceived success of a solution. Especially when the student might be asking you to do just that. So it is important to think about what it means for a student to succeed in this model. Success is rarely the learning goal, but rather the way the student arrives at the solution. When I have facilitated Problem-Based Learning in the past, I had to constantly remind myself of this and would often repeat this sentence: Do not steal learning opportunities from your students. 

Think about your learning journey. When you are faced with a problem that feels big and overwhelming and maybe beyond what you know, you manage to get to the solution or the answer through your own critical thinking. Isn’t there a spark of dopamine and joy when that happens? So even if a student is asking to have their learning opportunities stolen, resist. Answer their questions with questions. Push them to critically think. And when they get there, they too will get that spark of dopamine and joy for the learning that they can own and take with them. I believe that is what a transformative learning experience looks like.

Whether it is in a 100 level course, or a 600 level course, or an overly ambitious winter house project, or a decision on a new job, critical thinking is an essential part of being successful in any of them. Being an instructor for these students is a great opportunity to provide space to practice those skills and prepare them for life after graduation.

Please reach out if you have any questions or would like to discuss Problem-Based Learning further. If you are interested in diving deeper into the world of PBL, consider joining us for a 2 day iTeach event on May 7-8. More details and registration information can be found on the Center for Teaching and Learning’s website.

References 

Bezanilla, M. J., Galindo-Domínguez, H., & Poblete, M. (2021). Importance of Teaching Critical Thinking in Higher Education and Existing Difficulties According to Teacher’s Views. REMIE-Multidisciplinary Journal of Educational Research, 11(1).

Browne, M. N., Keeley, S. M., & Vasudeva, M. (2018). Asking the right questions: A guide to critical thinking. (12th ed.). Pearson. Chapter 2.

Major, C. H., Savin-Baden, M., & MacKinnon, M. (2000). Issues in problem-based learning: A message from the guest editors. Journal on Excellence in College Teaching, 11 (2&3), 1-10.

Marra, R., Jonassen, D. H., Palmer, B., & Luft, S. (2014). Why problem-based learning works: Theoretical foundations. Journal on Excellence in College Teaching, 25(3&4), 221-238.

Seibert, S. A. (2020). Problem-based learning: A strategy to foster generation Z’s critical thinking and perseverance. Teaching and Learning in Nursing, 16(1), 85–88.

Zach Cureton-Hazard

Zach Cureton-Hazard

Instructional Designer
MILL Makerspace Lead

zcureton@alaska.edu