Transformative Learning in Your Class

What kinds of experiences lend themselves to being ‘transformative’? Are they on par with astronauts being in earth orbit for the first time and viewing the entire planet? Would they be similar to the fabled prisoners of Plato’s cave being freed and seeing that the real world is not composed of shadows and puppets? What Transformative Learning Theory (TL) tells us is that a learner undergoes transformation when their frame of reference is changed. Jack Mezirow began crafting that theory in the late 1970s. He described one’s frame of reference as encompassing cognitive, conative, and emotional components, and being composed of two dimensions: habits of mind and a point of view [1]. As Mezirow states, habits of mind are quite resistant to change.

Mezirow began to postulate about what could cause change in one’s frame of reference. A precipitating factor would be something on the order of a major life event or exposure to significantly new ideas and practices. Mezirow called factors like these ‘disorienting dilemmas’. A dilemma capable of causing critical reflection in a learner might be something calamitous in their life, but could also be triggered by an eye-opening discussion, piece of literature or artwork. It is by trying to reconcile one’s previous way of knowing, feeling, and interpreting the world with new ideas and practices that give rise to one self examining previous assumptions and ways of thinking. This is what Mezirow called perspective transformation [2].

Takeaways

  • Transformative Learning (TL) has been a part of adult learning theory since the late 1970s.
  • TL can be precipitated by life changing events, carefully constructed classroom environments or students practicing metacognition in their learning.
  • Attempting to create Transformative experiences for students is a daunting task for the sole instructor, but more realistic for an entire University Community. ​

Another characteristic of a disorienting dilemma is that it can be quite threatening to the potential learner. Fortunately we and our coursework are not always going to give cause to a student and force them to reconsider their frames of reference with each lesson or in a threatening manner. There must be another way to foster transformative learning besides the use of disorienting dilemmas. 

In 2000, Edward Taylor published a review [3] of the then current literature. He summarized findings as it related to best practices in creating environments within the sphere of adult education where TL could occur without threatening dilemmas. In other words, Taylor sought to delineate the factors that would contribute to students changing their frames of reference in a more calm manner. He developed a list of conditions and practices which would foster the development of TL circumstances:

Ideal conditions to foster transformative learning:

  • Provide a safe, open, and trusting environment
  • Encourage student autonomy and collaboration with a learner centered approach
  • Arrange activities that encourage exploration of alternate perspectives and critical reflection

Practices which contribute to transformative learning environments:

  • Teach with trust, empathy and care
  • Demonstrate authenticity and integrity
  • Discuss and work through emotions and feelings before critical reflection
  • Instruct with storytelling and narrative
  • Assess with feedback and self review
  • Provide time for solitude and self-dialogue

Taylor was careful to note that some of these practices may not be in every instructor’s skill set, and that most of them take time to develop. It takes large amounts of time to develop such a nourishing learning environment.

Recently, two authors, Hoggan and Kloubert, took a new look at Transformative Learning theory as well as practical applications in the classroom. They noted that in addition to Mezirow’s dilemma’s and Taylor’s carefully constructed nurturing environments, many students in adult education are already at a place in their lives where change is about to occur. After again surveying the literature, Hoggan and Kloubert write about their ‘intuitive’ idea that many students, at some point in their college career will be at the point where they start to develop epistemological self-awareness as a result of normal intellectual, emotional and social growth that typically occurs in adult education. They offer that this is in itself potentially transformative [4].

Many of the students that attend UAF come from other areas of the State or world. Many will be aware from their childhood homes, will have to transition to adult responsibilities, will be exposed to a variety of new concepts from their degree field, other required coursework, and from their peers in attendance. They may be exposed to life changing opportunities like fieldwork, a chance to experience the arts, research and social life, in a way that is completely new to them.

What we can do as instructors is still follow the advice of the previously mentioned authors in recognizing what the potential change factors are in student’s lives, but also maintain an environment where students feel safe to discuss, debate and explore new external ideas, as well as indulge in some metacognition. We can require, and better yet, encourage critical self reflection in not only their learning, but also their emotional and intellectual reactions to learning.

In this manner, we can help provide what the Board of Regents recognized as UAF’s vision statement: Excellence through transformative experiences.

References

[1] Mezirow, J. (1997). Transformative learning: Theory to practice. New directions for adult and continuing education, 1997(74), 5-12.

[2] Mezirow, J. (1990). Fostering critical reflection in adulthood (pp. 1-20). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers.

[3] Taylor, E. (2000). Fostering Mezirow’s transformative learning theory in the adult education classroom: A critical review. Canadian Journal for the Study of Adult Education, 14(2), 1-28.

[4] Hoggan, C., & Kloubert, T. (2020). Transformative learning in theory and practice. Adult Education Quarterly, 70(3), 295-307.

Dan Lasota

Dan LaSota

Instructional Designer
Certified QM Peer Reviewer
Certified QM Training Facilitator

dlasota@alaska.edu